Thursday, January 7, 2010

Elliott Smith - Cecilia/Amanda

Track Review
Pitchfork
January 7, 2010
Link
7













After three discs of posthumous songs, most musicians don't have a whole lot of gold left in the vault. Elliott Smith's spiritual brother in intimate, depressive folk-pop, Nick Drake, made it to one rarities collection before lapsing into mediocrity. John Lennon got one half of a studio album and a couple of barrel-scratching Anthology tracks. Jimi Hendrix, for whatever it's worth, was releasing unreleased songs to some critical acclaim well into the second decade after his death (though I gotta admit I haven't heard many of them). So there's no reason Smith-- who recorded songs constantly, and, judging by some of his latter-career creative choices, wasn't necessarily the best judge of his own talent, anyway-- might not still have a couple of worthwhile recordings that haven't yet found a home.

"Cecilia/Amanda" is one, though it's not exactly greatest-hits material. With bleak but rich imagery that evokes the deadly "party dress" of Elvis Costello's "Alison" almost the way XO's "Baby Britain" turned over Revolver, Smith sings of a damaged female duo and "a place where lonely men pay to make their opposites match." It's still unclear who exactly belongs to whom, but a baby is definitely involved. Remastering by Tape Op editor Larry Crane nicely cleans up the keyboards and acoustic strums from the muddled version that has been floating around for a few years. Given that the tune dates back to Smith's high school band-- he recorded this take with Crane in 1997-- it's a good bet Smith didn't consider it one of his best. You won't need him to tell you that, but you'll be happy to hear another reliably well-constructed folk-pop song from the late singer/songwriter just the same. Even if part of his romantic charm was that he always strived for something more.
 

Search This Blog

Press Mentions

"Goes over the top and stays there to very nice effect."
-- David Carr, The New York Times

"I wasn't fully convinced. But I was interested."
-- Rob Walker, The New York Times

"...as Marc Hogan wrote in Spin..."
-- Maureen Dowd, The New York Times

Blog Archive